redressalert

Anonymous asked:

Problem with showing offense at the pronoun thing is it outs one as a non-genderist, which among the sorts who "ask pronouns" is socially dangerous. Often, just quietly being a GNC woman who uses "she" is enough to make them suspicious/unfriendly :(

redressalert answered:

Right, trust me—I know. But what the actual hell, how did it become okay to erase that we are *also* what women are? And why doesn’t it matter when *we* are triggered and offended? Why is it offensive for us to name OURSELVES however we see fit and why are our legitimate and entirely understandable feelings about this practice so taboo? Why are we being told to swallow the damage and keep smiling and pretending? And why are some of us so good at doing just that, almost as though we have been trained into such behavior all our lives? Why is it implicitly acknowledged that our claiming ourselves as “SHE” has an impact on the collective reality, but there’s no acknowledgment in the other direction? That those who name themselves otherwise, also impact us?

And if we don’t stand up to it and speak our piece, where do you see this trajectory going?

Do you want little girls growing up thinking that someone who is like you can’t possibly be a woman? Because that’s what I am encountering, and I owe it to these young ones—and to everyone—to show them we are possible, AS IS.

Socially dangerous. Anon, I feel you. I do. You think I am not scared? I am scared. When I talk to my older friends about these kinds of fears they say, “So you all are afraid of social ostracism, losing jobs, losing housing situations, losing friends and family, being made an example of, targeted for abuse…in some ways, sounds similar to what it was like to be a closeted lesbian.”

Being a dyke or a noncompliant woman of any kind has been socially dangerous, not to mention dangerous dangerous, since the advent of patriarchy. Men are, in general, dangerous and we threaten their social order when we resist compliance with their norms, when we dare to define for ourselves what female experience is and means, outside of their gaze and their agendas for us.

Women have recourse against the trials of mensland only in building social bonds and sharing resources with each other. When whole networks of women get colonized by a misogynist paradigm that becomes the coin of the realm; when denying your own reality becomes the price of admission, yeah—you are going to feel scared. Because you know we don’t survive well on our own and you are not an island, but how is this false “belonging” really any better? It looks impossible because you think you are alone, but there are more of us than we know. You and I have to speak up and see who meets us there.

Socially dangerous. The “gender” movement of the 90s really banked on the kind of “outlaw” rebel appeal that made such a thing seem sexy and cool. I gotta say that I should’ve known I wasn’t fighting the actual power because it was nothing like this.

“Do you want little girls growing up thinking that someone who is like you can’t possibly be a woman? Because that’s what I am encountering, and I owe it to these young ones—and to everyone—to show them we are possible, AS IS.”

redressalert gender critical detransition gender critical parenting

hajandradeye:

Meg Allen: Butch

“BUTCH is an environmental portraiture project and exploration of the butch aesthetic, identity and presentation of female masculinity as it stands in 2013-14. It is a celebration of those who dwell outside of the stringent social binary that separates the sexes and a glimpse into the private and often unseen spaces of people who exude their authentic sense of self.

In recent years, like so many other pejorative terms used to oppress minorities, BUTCH is being reclaimed and infused with beauty and pride to more accurately describe a person who claims their female masculinity. These people may choose to cut their hair short, may wear ties, or may swagger with more strength than coyness. BUTCH is an adjective. And like all adjectives, it is fluid and subjective. Just as there are many types of hot women, there are many types of butches. 

These portraits are of the people I know in the San Francisco Bay Area who relate to and claim the term BUTCH. These people are my friends, friends of friends, and are part of a very large gay and queer community world wide. Starting in the spring of 2013, in a effort to practice portraiture, I asked some of my closest butch friends to risk being seen by the lens and sit for me in their private environments. After printing and displaying my first three portraits, I realized I wanted a whole wall of these images. The wall turned into a room and the room into an online gallery. I then wondered what would it have been like to grow up surrounded by these images in addition to the ubiquitous feminine I saw in most magazines. …”

"BUTCH is a celebration of those who choose to exist and identify outside of this binary that has never allowed any accepted crossover. BUTCH is inviting viewers into private lives of female masculinity and suggesting a resilience in nature’s insistence that there is more depth to masculinity and femininity than societal norms care to entertain. Who is policing gender presentation, and why? The fashion world has been asking the same question for ages. Are we ready for the answers now? It is undeniable that we are born with the sex organs that we are born with, but why are so we threatened by what others choose to claim as their gender presentation? Are we ready for these explanations? Or are we more afraid of the question?

BUTCH is an exploration. BUTCH exists. BUTCH is an homage to the bull-daggers, dykes, manly women and female husbands before me. BUTCH is acceptance to the baby butches, young studs, gender queers, and dykes that continue to bloom in the face of societal norms.”

butch gender critical detransition gender critical parenting

Psychologists whose brains have been eaten by gender zombies

radfem-momma:

4thwavenow:

“Gender” therapist: Oh, it is VERY VERY rare for a 16-year-old who says they are transgender to really be lesbian.

Me: Hm. Oh, really? Well, she has only had relationships with girls, watches nothing but lesbian love stories on TV, and, um, just started talking about all this last week. She never talked about being a boy before that YouTube binge.

“Gender” therapist: Well, I know you’re scared and it must be so hard to accept this.

Me: No, actually, I just don’t buy it. I’m not scared. I’m angry.

“Gender” therapist (nodding sympathetically, while thinking, “what a transphobe”): Uh, huh. Well, you know, there is nothing you or I can do if she is actually transgender. 

Me: So, all she has to do is SAY she is and that’s it?

“Gender” therapist: I’m sorry, we’re out of time. That will be $150.

My daughter goes to high school with two trans identifying teens. The female trans kid’s mom won’t let them take testosterone, because “its worse for your health than smoking 2 packs a day”, and my daughter feels really bad for them because of it. No understanding of what its like to be in charge of your child’s future health. You’re not the only sane one out there. That kid is getting transferred to a weird charter school where they work outside on a farm a lot of the day, I think that mom has the right idea. If my daughter moves from “non-binary” to trans her internet is getting turned off immediately.

Nail, meet head. “No understanding of what it’s like to be in charge of your future child’s health.” But be careful. My daughter imbibed the KoolAid before I put any limits on the Internet. While it’s not a daily topic of conversation now, she is as hellbent as ever. I’d work on deprogramming proactively, if I had it to do over.

radfem-momma gender critical teen transition gender critical parenting
twentythreetimes-deactivated201

rainbowreject:

Seriously though I just get angry sometimes about how much truscum fucked me up when I was already in a vulnerable position being 17 and just having dropped out of school after coming out as a lesbian and being bullied for it and then having them pressure me into having…

I listen a lot to the voices of detransitioned FTMs. They give me inspiration and hope. Thanks to each and every one of you for generously sharing your often painful experiences with the rest of us. 

twentythreetimes-deactivated201 gender critical detransition gender critical parenting

throughalleternity asked:

Have you seen studies that show that trans brains are different from other people's brains and are more similar to the gender that they identify as? I've seen some (only in regard to male/female genders) and am curious of your opinion on them.

I have seen some of those studies. There are also studies showing just the opposite (that there is no such thing as a male/female brain). There have ALWAYS been women (and men) who embody characteristics traditionally considered to belong to the opposite sex, and in my view we should celebrate those outliers rather than pathologizing them.  But let’s assume there is some validity to the studies you mention. For me, the existential question is this: Which is the more compassionate, less risky, and more inclusive response: (1.) to DEconstruct gender (as we Second Wave feminists started to do) and encourage people to express themselves in (more conventionally understood) “masculine” or “feminine” ways as they choose, while accepting the bodies they actually are, or (2.) to leap to the conclusion that the one and only solution to the problem of “feeling” like the opposite sex is to attack it with a surgeon’s scalpel and steroids, which can cause serious health problems that must be monitored and managed? Just because the medical profession CAN create a facsimile of a male from a female body, should it? For me, the choice is clear (except in a few rare cases, primarily intersex people).

 I fully understand WHY a person feels they need to change their body to match their mind, but the very idea that there is such a thing as a male or female brain is really just that—an idea. If a female dog behaves more like a male dog, does the female dog think about acquiring a penis? We can’t know, and of course, we aren’t dogs, but we ARE animals, exquisite products of evolution. I resonate with the poet Mary Oliver’s advice: “You only have to let the soft animal of your body love what it loves.”

gender critical trans brains gender critical parenting

Anonymous asked:

If you have access to a university library, Joseph de Rivera wrote a paper called "The Construction of False Memory Syndrome: The Experience of Retractors". It's in Psychological Inquiry, 1997, Volume 8, Number 4. The paper discusses how people went through stages of using remembered abuse to explain other problems in their lives, centering their identities on that belief, and cutting off anyone who doubted the abuse. As in modern gender therapy, believer therapists guided this process.

Thank you for this reference. The feminist community fell hook-line-sinker for this too for a number of years, with devastating results for some families. The sad thing is that sexual abuse of children is very real, but there is little evidence that memories of abuse are easily forgotten or suppressed. Family members who questioned false allegations were demonized and bonds broken. I fear this is the same thing that is happening with so many teens who dismiss their parents as “transphobic” for daring to question the dominant paradigm.

Below is an excerpt from the abstract to your referenced article:
Abstract: More than 300 persons have now retracted charges of childhood sexual abuse (CSA) based on “memories” recovered in psychotherapy. How may we understand their experience? …The accounts of the retractors and their critique of different explanations are presented. ..In all cases, the experiences of the retractors appeared to be determined more by the therapeutic situation than by characteristics of their personalities.

gender critical gender critical parenting

It’s often denied by transactivists, but there is a very active and assertive online community that pressures young people who are just beginning to question their identities to hurry, hurry, hurry. Any doubts are quickly dismissed, and advice is dispensed for obtaining (dangerous) black market hormones. This is one of many excellent posts from a website that is actively documenting this online indoctrination. 

gender critical teen transition gender critical parenting

throughalleternity asked:

I think the most important thing is too be open and to listen. Being unable to transition can be very painful and cause depression/suicidal thoughts, so if your child is transgender, this can help prevent further distress. But to sun it up, I (3/?)

I’m gonna touch this one. Teen suicide is the most horrible thing imaginable, and we all need to do whatever we can to prevent it.  The pain and dissociation from one’s own body is very real. That said, the dominant trans paradigm says suicidal ideation is solely the result of transphobia and the lack of parental support for “transition.” But maybe, just maybe, some of these young people want to die because 21st century society is giving them the message that they cannot be, cannot live legitimately and happily in the bodies they have. That if they don’t like “girly” things or are “sissy boys” they must insist upon a medical diagnosis that will commit them to a chronic, expensive health condition involving lifelong drug treatment and repeated plastic surgeries;  that they will have to live like Type 1 diabetics, requiring treatment for the rest of their natural lives. That they are being taught to dissociate. How can that not contribute to a sense of hopelessness and despair?

We on the left cannot allow all the questions about transgenderism to be hijacked by the radical, theocratic right. This is not about sin and hellfire. This is about rational thinking and the courage to question progressive dogma.

gender critical teen transition detransition gender critical parenting

Anonymous asked:

I'm a 21 year old lesbian who has watched a number of her friends declare themselves to be 'genderqueer' or ftm rather than the seemingly dirty word of lesbian or even woman. I'm gnc and constantly asked what my preferred pronouns are. When I proudly say SHE it is met with derision and a sneer as if I'll soon grow out of it. This new attack on womanhood is frightening. Thank you for creating this blog and posting the truth.

Keep the faith. It gives me hope and courage just hearing from young women like you. I recommend immersing yourself in some of the lesbian feminist literature and music from the Second Wave: Meg Christian, Cris Williamson, Teresa Trull, and many others. I look forward to more out lesbian performers as we move out of Peak Trans.

lesbophobia gender critical teen transition detransition gender critical parenting