One of the key discoveries of neuroscience in the late 20th
and early 21st centuries is the extraordinary malleability of the
human brain throughout the life span. Neuroplasticity—the
ability of even an adult brain to change firing patterns and regenerate neurons
in response to experience—is yet another aspect of settled human knowledge that
is being ignored in the rush to diagnose children and adolescents as transgender
and in need of medical intervention.
But you don’t even need the latest findings in neuroscience
to poke a giant hole in transactivist logic.
Long before scientists established that adult brains are so malleable, it
has been known that kids’ brains are far more neuroplastic than those of adults.
It’s why a child can recover near total function after a brain injury or stroke
in a way an adult cannot. It’s why kids become fluent in multiple languages
with no “foreign” accent. Their brains have to be plastic–how else could they
learn and change throughout childhood?
Those involved in transgender activism and pediatric treatment—who say
they have science on their side—have a standard line about puberty blockers, the use of “preferred pronouns,” and all the rest of the childhood gender
dysphoria dogma: “It won’t harm the child. Only the truly transgendered will choose
medical transition after puberty. The rest (the majority) will choose their natal
sex.” (Of course there are no published studies on this, although there is
plenty of data showing that most gender dysphoric kids grow up to be gay,
lesbian, or bisexual if simply left alone by “gender specialists” and scared parents.)
But the assertion that pediatric gender therapists and MDs are
doing no harm (like the rest of the flimsy rationalizations they use) flies in
the face of basic, settled neuroscience.
Because of neuroplasticity, those kids who have been “identified
as” transgender and treated as the opposite sex throughout childhood will be
influenced and molded by that experience (as they are molded by all the other
experiences they have). In effect, they will learn the idea that
their bodies “don’t match” their gender
via their childhood
experiences. Unlike any other transient childhood fantasy (e.g., that they are actually Batman), they will be repeatedly validated in the idea that biological reality–their actual bodies–is mistaken, and must eventually be changed to match their subjective feelings. What they think, even how their brains are wired, will be
influenced by what they are told, and
how they are treated by everyone around them. What would happen if a child with body integrity identity disorder (BIID) was repeatedly validated in the idea that (say) their left leg was “wrong” and should eventually be amputated?
Every other field of science has taken neuroplasticity into
account in decisions about best treatment. For the current treatments for
gender dysphoric kids to make any sense at all, you have to believe that the
brain is fixed, unchangeable from birth, and completely impervious to life experience. In other words—the exact
opposite of what reams of brain research and clinical experience have taught us
in the last several decades.
This antiquated notion of a static brain creates such a huge
logical hole in the pediatric transgender rationale, the entire flimsy edifice should eventually collapse if
scientists and clinicians ever get the courage to base their treatments and
recommendations on actual evidence
and science.
*******
Postscript: Think I’m wrong? I’d love to see some researchers step up to do a longitudinal study comparing two groups of adults who were: (1.) Dysphoric kids who were sent to gender therapists and called by their preferred pronouns, given puberty blockers, and otherwise validated in their idea that they are “trapped in the wrong body” and (2.) Dysphoric kids who were supported for just being themselves, regardless of gender stereotypes, as the sex and in the bodies they were born with, with no messaging or validation from “specialists” or parents that they are the opposite sex. How many remain dysphoric as adults and move on to medical transition after childhood?
Who’s recruiting? (Hint: no one.) Time to get started!
